Best Coffee Maker Without Plastic: Non-Toxic and BPA Free

You may be an ardent coffee fan. So much so that you need a new coffee machine to satiate your coffee cravings. But what if we tell you that you are risking your life? It is not the coffee that is to blame. It is a machine. Most of these coffee machines are made of plastic. Hence, they have coatings of a toxic substance called BPA. Thus, making them BPA coffee makers.

BPA (Bisphenol A) is found in polycarbonate plastics and resins. Polycarbonate plastics are used in producing durable and heavy plastics. Water bottles, food containers, cans, and several home appliances are often made up of this material. Likewise, some metal containers use a coating of epoxy resin which is made up of BPA. This is to avoid corrosion and breakage. 

Research shows that BPA can seep into the food/beverage from the container. It can hamper the workings of the brain, liver, thyroid gland, and immune system. However, the good news is that you can avoid this calamity. You can opt for plastic-free coffee makers. To save you some time, we have narrowed down some options for you.

Best Coffee Maker Without Plastic Comparison 2024

• Best for Budget-Friendly: No products found.
• Best for Delicate: No products found.
• Best for Durable: No products found.

No products found.

How Was This List Made?

When your health is at stake, we can’t afford to take any risks. We have been vigilant and attentive in picking out some of the best coffee makers without plastic. We deep-dived into the conversations of health-conscious consumers who selected plastic-free coffee makers. We took advice from Reddit. Moreover, we filtered through the details of several non-toxic coffee makers. So, believe us when we say that the 5 choices given below are amongst the safest coffee makers.

How Was This List Made?

To ensure a perfectly suited coffee maker, you need to be mindful of its usage and capacity. The amount of time it takes is an important factor. And whether you will prefer glass, steel, or BPA-free plastic when opting for BPA-free coffee makers. Keeping all that in mind, let’s take a look at the list.

Best Coffee Maker Without Plastic: Non-Toxic and BPA Free

OXO Brew 9 Cup Coffee Maker

No products found.

At first look, OXO Brew Coffee maker seems like missing some parts. There is only one visible button on the body. As you fiddle with it, you realize it’s magical. A single button can do it all. You can set the time for your coffee. All you need is to twist the button. And then, you can press for the number of cups you need. The digital interface also lets you know when your coffee has started brewing. A small sign tells you the status. Such is its engineering.

The machine is made with a combination of glass, stainless steel, and BPA-free plastic. It can make you as large as 9 cups. It makes use of the pour-over method to deliver the best taste possible. At the same time, it comes with a thermal carafe. The coffee you get is always hot. Much hotter than you expect. 

The best part of this coffee maker is the SCAA approval. SCAA is a non-profit body that has set parameters for home-style coffee makers. For a machine to pass through its rigorous tests, is not easy.  Only a few could achieve the SCAA certification. The machine undergoes 3 important tests. It should brew within a certain time, at a certain temperature. There is also a golden cup criterion that guarantee’s a near-perfect extraction. Hence every cup from this machine matches the gold-standard flavor by SCAA.

Another interesting fact is the pause and brew element. The coffee maker takes a pause every now and then. You might feel there is a flaw in there. But, this process ensures full extraction. It shows how passionate the coffee maker is to get you a rich cup. However, it does take 6-7 mins for a brew. I guess you can devote that much time, at least.

Pros

• SCAA approved
• BPA-free components used
• Minimalist design

Cons

• Residual water dripping from the filter

Verdict: Needs to be added

Cuisinart DCC-1200 Brew Central

No products found.

Cuisinart brew central is one that gives you a lot under budget. It has a brushed stainless steel finish. However, the body is made up of plastic. But don’t worry because it is BPA-free plastic. The makers have labeled the product to prove the same. 

The machine has the capacity to make 12 cups of coffee. The makers are smart enough. They know 12 cups at one go is rare. That is why we have a 1-4 cup button on the machine. Suppose you want to rise with the smell of coffee. The machine has a 24-hour advance brew setting. It also has an auto shutdown from 0 mins-4 hours. So up to 4 hours, your coffee can stay hot. 

There is one more unique feature. The machine lets you choose the carafe temperature. If you continuously complain about coffee getting cold. This feature might actually help you savor your coffee while it is hot. The charcoal and gold-tone filter ensures a fresh flavor to your coffee. The filter can be re-used. Hence avoiding wastage through filter paper.

Pros

• Within budget
• BPA free plastic
• The capacity of 12 cups
• Can adjust the carafe temperature

Cons

• Has breakdown issues in the long run

Verdict: Cuisinart DC1200 coffee maker is the best non-toxic coffee maker in the budget. It is a semi-automatic device. You can brew as many as 12 cups. There are some interesting features too. Likewise, it has a great design. Altogether, it is a steal under this price.

Presto 02811 12-Cup Stainless Steel Coffee Maker

No products found.

Suppose a glass coffee maker is not easy for you to handle. Then, this might be your best choice. Presto’s stainless steel coffee maker is durable and will last ages. Most importantly, it is a non-toxic coffee maker made of stainless steel. You can assure yourself that no harmful toxin will enter your body through your coffee maker. Even the filter basket and the perk tube are made up of stainless steel. Consequently, as per the design, it appears traditional. 

Presto is amongst the coffee percolator types. Meaning it is a type of pot that brews coffee using gravity. In other words, when boiling water seeps through the grounds, gravity forces hot coffee down the strainer. The process takes less than a minute. A red light on the percolator will indicate whenever your cup is ready. Though, it makes more than a cup. Surely, it can make you 2-12 cups, depending upon your needs. To cater to your needs, it comes in two different sizes with a capacity of 6 cups and 12 cups.

Not only is the stainless steel durable, but easy to maintain and handle. Consumers suggest cleaning the pot with non-abrasive materials to maintain the shine. Thus ensuring everlasting beauty. No matter if it is loved by a lot of consumers.  

Pros

• Sturdy material
• Easy to care
• Easy to handle
• BPA free

Cons

• Simple looking machine
• Complaints of coffee getting burnt if kept for long

Verdict: Presto stainless steel coffee maker is the best stainless steel coffee maker without plastic. It is durable and easy to handle. So you need not worry about manhandling. With as little effort as possible, it can give you anything between 2 to 12 cups. All you need is some water and ground coffee. Apart from the traditional design, there is nothing that can let you down on this one.

Chemex Classic Series, Pour-over Glass Coffeemaker

No products found.

Chemex coffeemaker is a manual pour-over glass coffee maker. It is designed in a unique hourglass shape. The non-porous borosilicate glass avoids bad odors and chemical residues. The upper filter and the lower glass are bound by an elegant piece of wood. For its magnificent design, the coffee maker has been included in the collection of the Museum of Modern Art in New York City. 

It is a beauty with brains. Meaning it not only looks good but tastes good too. The coffee maker uses thick filters made up of bonded paper. This ensures a cleaner and stronger drip while removing any bitter notes. The makers recommend a medium-coarse grind to be used. It gives around 8 cups of coffee at a single time. You can drink some and preserve the rest. That, too, without losing any flavor. You can heat it later on a glass stove or a gas flame. 

With an all-glass body, the Chemex is one of the safest coffee makers. Even the kettle is made up of heat-resistant glass to prevent heat loss.  All you need to do is to add coffee to the filter and wait for the grounds to bloom. After 25 seconds, add more water and see the beauty coming down in the filter below.

Pros

• Easy to use
• Non-plastic body, thus BPA free
• Compact, elegant design

Cons

• Uses Chemex filters only
• Glass is prone to breakage
• The most expensive in the category

Verdict: Chemex Classic Series, Pour-over Glass Coffeemaker, is the best in the category for plastic-free coffee makers. The elegance of the machine will force you to buy one for your kitchen. It is easy to use and gives a delightful eight cups of coffee. However, this beauty needs to be handled with care. Adding to it is its price, which makes the handling even more important. So, if you can manage all this, then it can serve as the healthiest coffee maker.

Mueller French Press

No products found.

If your budget is a bit less, then Mueller’s French press can be a good option for you. One that is non-toxic. A French press uses coarsely grounded coffee immersed in a beaker filled with water.  Then, it is set aside for around 4 mins. As a result, the water extracts the flavor from the coffee. Finally, the mesh plunger is inserted to collect the coffee grounds. The 4 layers inside it assure you of a clean cup without any residue. You can then pour and drink your delicious cup.

This french press is made up of 301 quality stainless steel.  As far as looks are concerned, the machine has a glass finish. Together, it is a rust-free, long-lasting product. Having a medium-size capacity of 34 ounces. The double insulation technique keeps hot coffee hot and cold coffee cold for as long as an hour. The duration is much more than any glass or steel press can claim.

Not to forget, the stainless steel body makes it a non-toxic coffee maker. In terms of usage, it is not only for coffee but has more to it. You can make tea, froth milk, and make various herbal drinks with it. Moreover, the makers provide you with a matching travel canister. So, you can make this a constant companion.

Pros

• High-quality stainless steel
• Budget-friendly
• Portable

Cons

• As a french press, it takes more time to brew
• Finer coffee will require more force
• Boiling water needs to be added
• If the coffee stays for long, it might turn bitter

Verdict: If you want to save some bucks, you can opt for Mueller’s french press. The high-quality steel body is durable and elegant. Adding to this is the fact that it is one of the healthiest coffee makers. You can use it as and when with little care or effort. Though, if you need instant coffee, it might not be the best option. Also, residual coffee grounds can cause some trouble.

Buying Guide: What to look for in a coffee maker without plastic

Look for BPA-free labels

BPA-coated materials affect your health severely.  Studies have shown that it has a direct impact on your hormones, especially estrogen. Thus affecting growth, cell development, fetal growth, and reproduction. If you want to avoid this, look for BPA-free labels. Several coffee makers give an assurance of the same. Especially the ones made of plastic. You need to look for the label before buying your non-toxic coffee maker.

Material & Durability

Coffee machines, under BPA-free conditions, come in three types. You can either opt for steel, glass, or BPA-free plastic. Stainless steel containers are durable and easy to handle and care for. However, they might look a bit traditional or simply looking. Though, some have an elegant glass finish that makes them stand out. While if you go for coffee makers made up of glass, they look more classy. You can watch the beautiful play of your drink being made. However, they are not easy to handle and are prone to breakage. 

The most sturdy option is BPA-free plastic machines. They are durable, handy, and easy to care for. However, according to some studies, they still contain other harmful chemicals. 

Capacity

What good can the safest coffee maker do if it can make you the number of cups you require? Non-plastic coffee machines can make you anywhere from 1 cup to 12 cups. So before setting out to buy a machine, make sure it suits your requirements. 

Ease of use

Suppose you are not keen on handling delicate coffee machines. You might think carefully before buying one made up of glass. They might look elegant but not if you are the clumsy type. You might as well go for stainless steel or plastic.

How long it takes for 1 cup

Suppose you are an impatient coffee drinker. The time taken by your machine must be important for you. Some of these take as less as 1 min, and some might take up to 8 mins for a perfect brew. So you need to be careful about brew timing.

Types of the coffee maker

Everybody has a preference for coffee machines. You might love a cup from a pour-over or a french press more than a percolator or semi-automatic machine. Before committing yourself to a coffee maker, you must be sure about the type. The reason is that different types of machines use different methods and hence might produce a different taste. 

Looks or design

If a coffee maker is not just a machine for you, then you might be careful about its design. A perfect-looking cup from a perfect-looking machine is everybody’s desire. You may have a traditional or a modern choice. It will influence the type of coffee maker you choose. And whether a good design is more important than the working of the machine for you.

Conclusion

As per our research, Presto stainless steel coffee maker stands as the most coveted choice for a non-toxic, BPA-free coffee maker. It is not only safe but durable too. You can use it until you get bored. The thick coffee filters give you a smooth coffee without residue. Apart from the simple-looking design, it has nothing for you to worry about.

James Mark

James is the owner of North. After working at Nick’s on Broadway, James moved to Red Fez and put his knowledge to the test with hot dog R&D. He assisted in the launch of Momofuku Ko in NYC In 2008. And a year later, James was part of Christina Tosi’s team for Momofuku Milk Bar as their bread baker.